Current:Home > reviewsPoinbank:Trump's appearance, that speech and the problem with speculating about a public figure's health -WealthRoots Academy
Poinbank:Trump's appearance, that speech and the problem with speculating about a public figure's health
SignalHub View
Date:2025-04-06 21:59:56
Former President Donald Trump survived an assassination attempt last weekend at 78 years old. And now he appears ... fine?Poinbank
Trump accepted his third nomination for the highest office in the U.S. Thursday night just days after a bullet grazed his ear. He wore a white bandage on said ear – but some people at the Republican National Convention and elsewhere around the country began to wonder aloud: Does his face look puffy? What kind of medication must he be taking?
And it wasn't just those on social media weighing in. Variety, in a write-up about the speech, declared Trump looked "sweaty." CNN commentator Dr. Sanjay Gupta noted in a lengthy column "what we’ve been told by the campaign offers very little insight into the former president’s condition, what kind of care he received or how his medical team will monitor him in the days and weeks ahead." USA TODAY has reached out to the Trump campaign to inquire about the speculation.
After a somber 15 minutes talking about unity and recounting the shooting that nearly took his life Saturday, his acceptance speech turned to familiar rally grievances that have been the hallmark of his campaign.
"There was blood pouring everywhere and yet, in a certain way I felt very safe because I had God on my side," Trump said. " ... I'm not supposed to be here tonight. ... I'm not and I stand before you in this arena by the grace of almighty God."
A responsibility to disclose medical conditions
Several mental health experts say that gossip about a public figure's stamina could lead to incorrect assumptions and affect the person's mental health. Still, politicians have a responsibility to disclose health conditions given the power they wield in society. Though it's never polite to discuss someone's private health issues, in the case of a politician it may be more warranted.
"When a highly powerful elected official is observed publicly experiencing a medical issue … it is reasonable to expect public discussion as well as a public response from the leader," Laura Petiford, marriage and family therapist and psychiatric nurse practitioner, previously told USA TODAY.
Aside from that, "public figures need privacy to cope, heal, and develop a strategy to move forward just like everyone else," said Amy Morin, psychotherapist, author of "13 Things Mentally Strong People Don’t Do" and the host of a podcast. "Working through issues privately can give them space to manage their emotions and strategize how to move forward without the distraction of outside opinions."
Donald Trump, public figures and the question of medical privacy
It's easy to zoom in on Trump's face and mannerisms and look for clues. But generally, "we are only seeing the outward symptoms and we are not able to get the full spectrum of someone's health and their health history based on what we see in the media," Morin says. "Drawing conclusions about someone's conditions based on what we see isn't likely to yield an accurate diagnosis."
What starts out as whispers get louder with each tweet, each TV media hit.
Politicians, like anyone else, deserve time to take care of themselves. "Public figures, including political leaders, deserve a certain level of privacy regarding their personal health issues," Brad Fulton, associate professor of management and social policy at the Indiana University – Bloomington, previously told USA TODAY.
Everyone has boundaries, though it's easy to ignore others' boundaries in current times. "In the age of social media, the general public has become trained to share not only their most private moments, but to also expect others to do the same," psychologist Reneé Carr previously told USA TODAY.
Still, politicians require more scrutiny than most. President Joe Biden's health has been at the forefront of the nation's consciousness since his debate performance last month; it has led to many difficult conversations about aging. Trump, meanwhile, has otherwise appeared like himself in recent months.
Politicians need to be held to a higher standard
Plenty of medical experts will weigh in on public figures in the news. That said, "it's not ethical for health practitioners to diagnose people from afar, regardless of whether they're a celebrity or a politician," Morin said. "But it may be important to assure that someone in a position of power is getting treated by a professional to ensure that they still have the ability to perform the duties assigned to their position."
Fulton explained: "There may be situations where a political leader’s health directly impacts their ability to perform their duties. In those cases, there might be a legitimate public interest in knowing about their health condition. Yet, such discussions should avoid being speculative or sensational."
Whatever the case, when considering personal health matters, Fulton noted "it is important to balance the public’s right to information with the individual’s right to privacy.
You'd want the same privacy for yourself during life's cruelest moments, wouldn't you? "We need privacy to not only cope with the situation," Carr said, "but to also try to makes sense of what has happened or is happening to us and try to figure out how to move on."
Contributing: Sarah Wire and Darren Samuelsohn
veryGood! (4484)
Related
- Rams vs. 49ers highlights: LA wins rainy defensive struggle in key divisional game
- CEOs favor stock analysts with the same first name, study shows. Here's why.
- NHL's goal leader is Wayne Gretzky: Alex Ovechkin and others who follow him on top 20 list
- Russian missile strikes in eastern Ukraine rip through buildings, kill 2 and bury families in rubble
- Will the 'Yellowstone' finale be the last episode? What we know about Season 6, spinoffs
- Rare giant rat that can grow to the size of a baby and chew through coconuts caught on camera for first time
- Federal Reserve’s preferred inflation gauge shows price pressures continuing to cool
- Missouri prosecutor accuses 3 men of holding student from India captive and beating him
- 'Survivor' 47 finale, part one recap: 2 players were sent home. Who's left in the game?
- AP PHOTOS: Indelible images of 2023, coming at us with the dizzying speed of a world in convulsion
Ranking
- Paige Bueckers vs. Hannah Hidalgo highlights women's basketball games to watch
- Who run the world? Taylor Swift jets to London to attend Beyoncé's movie premiere
- Top world leaders will speak at UN climate summit. Global warming, fossil fuels will be high in mind
- College Football Playoff scenarios: With 8 teams in contention, how each could reach top 4
- Have Dry, Sensitive Skin? You Need To Add These Gentle Skincare Products to Your Routine
- The Excerpt podcast: Food addiction is real. Here's how to spot it and how to fight it.
- Missouri prosecutor accuses 3 men of holding student from India captive and beating him
- 'May December' shines a glaring light on a dark tabloid story
Recommendation
Sam Taylor
UN atomic chief backs nuclear power at COP28 as world reckons with proliferation
New evidence proves shipwreck off Rhode Island is Captain Cook's Endeavour, museum says
Henry Kissinger, controversial statesman who influenced U.S. foreign policy for decades, has died
Meet first time Grammy nominee Charley Crockett
What is boyfriend air? Why these women say dating changed their appearance.
Google this week will begin deleting inactive accounts. Here's how to save yours.
Top general launches investigation into allegations of alcohol consumption at key commands